Skip to content


Christian Kanzian

Pages 409 - 412

In our ordinary life we normally regard the middle-sized objects of everyday’s world like cars, sheep, human beings as remaining ‘the same’ over time even if they change some of their properties. The problem of persistence starts with the question how we can justify such an assumption. The most radical solution is that there is no justification at all (even though we ‘intuitively’ hold that there should be one). Among the ‘radicalists’ we can distinguish between those (‘Parmenideans’) who consider change as illusionary, and those (‘Heracliteans’) who generally negate that things can remain the same.

1Department of Philosophy, Theological Faculty of the University Innsbruck

1 Barker, S.; Dowe, P., (2003). “Paradoxes of Multi-location”, Analysis 63: 106-14.

2 Beebee, H.; M. Rush, (2003). “Nonparadoxical Multi-location”, Analysis 63: 311-17.

3 Barker, S.; Dowe, P., (2005) “Endurance is Paradoxical”, Analysis 65: 69-74.

4 Haslanger, S., Kurtz, R. M. (eds.), (2006), Persistence: Contemporary Readings, Cambridge MA: MIT-Press.

5 Hawley, K., (2001), How Things Persist, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

6 Heller, M., (1990), The Ontology of Physical Objects, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

7 Johnston, M., (1987), “Is there a Problem about Persistence?”, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Suppl. Volume 61: 105-136.

8 Kanzian, C. (ed.) 2008, Persistence, Heusenstamm: Ontos.

9 Kanzian, C., (2016), Wie Dinge sind, Berlin/Boston: De Gruyter.

10 Lewis, D., (1986), On the Plurality of Worlds, Oxford: Blackwell.

11 Lowe, J., (1998), The Possibility of Metaphysics, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

12 Miller, K., (2005), “The Metaphysical Equivalence of Three and Four Dimensionalism”, Erkenntnis 62: 91-17.

13 Seibt, J., (1997), “Existence in Time: From Substance to Process”, in Faye, J.; Scheffler, U.; Urs, M. (eds.), Perspectives on Time. Boston Studies in Philosophy of Science, Dordrecht: Kluwer, 143-182.

14 Seibt, J., (2008), “Beyond Endurance and Perdurance: Recurrant Dynamics”, in Kanzian, C. (ed.), Persistence, Heusenstamm: Ontos, 133-164.

15 Sider, T., (2001), Four-dimensionalism: An Ontology of Persistence and Time, Oxford: University Press.

16 Simons, P., (1991), “On Being Spread out in Time”, in W. Spohn, and other eds. Existence and Explanation. Dordrecht: Kluwer, 131-147.

17 Smith, B.; Grenon, P., (2008), “Persistance and Ontological Pluralism”, in Kanzian op. cit.

18 Trettin, K., (2005), Substanz. Neue Überlegungen zu einer klassischen Kategorie des Seienden, Frankfurt: Klostermann.


Export Citation